Peter Pan Goes Wrong Review (Lyceum Theatre, Sheffield)

24 February 2024 I 19:45 I Lyceum Theatre, Sheffield

⭐⭐⭐

I have previously seen a lot of Mischief's work, which I have always adored. Unfortunately, something about Peter Pan Goes Wrong doesn't quite resonate with this familiarity. Humour is laboured at times, and Mischief fails to attempt overly original comedy away from their portfolio of work. Though often predictable, this play is very technically impressive, deserving all the commendations for the team behind the scenes (who get their own bow at the end!).

These high octane performances are known for their 200% energy, but a constant high can exhaust in a run time of 2hrs 10mins, easy to discount the best bits. Physical comedy is where this cast shines, most of all Phil Yarrow taking on roles Starkey and Nana, working miracles alongside Simon Scullion's set. Just when you think that everything possible has been done, a whole new scene emerges, levels of stage magic never before seen in the theatre.

With a wonderful pre-show, this is worth arriving early for, just the beginning for an incredible showcase of Matt Haskins' lighting across the entire auditorium. The relationship with the audience peaks with Jack Michael Stacey as Hook, bouncing off improvised interjections which is where the humour revels. Although, a pantomime aesthetic is encouraged occasionally. It stands stronger without this, where call-backs are overused and tedious. This prompts the audience to shout aloud when not appropriate, the rules too lax to be respected.

Jean-Luke Worrell is joyful through his Narrator, throwing sparkle at every opportunity! He makes use of his time with fantastic energy, a true star! Jamie Birkett is tremendous as Mrs Darling and Tinkerbell, vivid expression in her facial work. This allows every mishap to appear so frustrating, where occasionally it can feel for others that the gag is waiting to happen. Jake Burgum's Trevor has a humorous deal of nonchalance against the chaos. A delightful presence with his character work.

For me, Adam Meggido's direction is exhaustive on the comedy front, which could benefit from a more refined style. However, audiences howl with laughter, so clearly well received by the majority! I would never discourage anyone from watching the show in this regard.

Part of a shorter series of reviews, initially published on Instagram to manage university demand.